TS wrongly id’ed chicken
Our take
Have you ever found yourself questioning your chicken’s identity? You're not alone! One of our community members, u/gcd120904, recently shared their puzzling experience with a “Cinnamon Queen pullet” from Tractor Supply that started crowing—definitely not the behavior you’d expect from a lady! With their initial confidence in its gender based on the sex-linked traits, they're left wondering if a mischievous Rhode Island Red cockerel slipped in by accident or if it’s a different breed altogether. It’s a classic case of chicken confusion! If you're also scratching your head over your feathered friends, check out our article "Friend or Foe?" for more insights into the quirky personalities of roosters. Let's dive into this cluck-tastic mystery together!
In the whimsical world of poultry, few things are as confounding as the age-old question of gender identification among our beloved feathered friends. The recent Reddit post about a “cinnamon queen pullet” that turned out to be a crowing cockerel is a perfect example of why even the most seasoned chicken enthusiasts can find themselves scratching their heads in bewilderment. As the original poster speculated about the possibility of a Rhode Island Red (RIR) mix-up at the store, we’re reminded of our own experiences with unexpected surprises in the coop. After all, who hasn’t felt the pang of confusion when their supposed hen suddenly starts sounding more like a rooster? This delightful conundrum is just one of many that keep us bonded as a community, much like the sentiments shared in our pieces like Friend or Foe? and Greeting from Piep and Churp.
The beauty of raising chickens lies not only in the fresh eggs and the delightful clucking but also in the quirky personalities that each bird brings to the yard. It’s a playful dance of discovery as we learn to navigate the intricacies of chicken breeds and their behaviors. But this story has a deeper significance—it's a reminder that even with the best of intentions and knowledge, sometimes things just don’t go according to plan. Mistakes happen—whether at the hatchery or in our own backyards—and they serve as a humbling lesson in our journey as chicken keepers. Perhaps this is why we can all relate to the plight of our fellow chicken lover, as we’ve likely faced a moment of uncertainty ourselves.
Moreover, this tale of mistaken identity raises an important conversation about the need for transparency and accuracy in poultry sourcing. As we continue to embrace the joys of backyard farming, it becomes increasingly essential for suppliers like Tractor Supply to ensure that their labeling and identification processes are as accurate as possible. This isn’t just about avoiding confusion—it's about fostering trust within our community of chicken keepers. When we invest time, energy, and love into raising our “feathered friends,” we deserve to know what we’re actually getting. Mislabeling could lead to a host of challenges, not to mention the emotional rollercoaster that comes with raising a rooster when one was hoping for a dozen eggs from hens!
As we reflect on this amusing yet thought-provoking situation, it leads us to ponder: What does this mean for our future as poultry enthusiasts? Are we prepared to embrace the unexpected twists and turns that come with this adventure? The lively exchange of tales and experiences—like the recent post about “Another smol chicken hotdog” (link)—reminds us that every chicken, regardless of its classification, adds a unique flavor to our lives. The chicken community thrives on shared experiences, and as we learn from each other, we can navigate the inevitable surprises with humor and camaraderie.
So, the next time you find yourself questioning the identity of your feathered friend, remember: you’re not alone in this delightful chaos. Embrace the quirks, laugh at the absurdities, and let’s keep the conversation going. Who knows? The next crow you hear might just lead to a new adventure worth clucking about!

| We got this “cinnamon queen pullet” from tractor supply, and as it started getting the adolescence feathers, we were positive it was a girl since Cinnamon Queens are sex-linked and CQ Roos are white. But this Queen crowed, so there are obvious doubts on what the breed could be 😅 [link] [comments] |
Read on the original site
Open the publisher's page for the full experience
Related Articles
- Hen or Rooster? …. Or both?!Yesterday I posted about my ‘roosters’ head shaking behaviour, and I was told this is actually a hen, or it was intersex, or it was a rooster. I’ve taken some better pictures and I’d love to know your opinion It does not crow, I’ve had it for a week only and prior owner says it attempts to and then goes silent after the first 0.5 seconds of what sound like a crow… It’s extremely protective of the rest of the flock and acts like a rooster, walks around quite up right and dominate. I am told it is a Partridge Laced Wyandotte, I am not sure if it’s cross breed, google shows me that roosters do not come in this colouring, and that wing shape looks hen to me but I am no chicken scientist Thank you! one very confused chicken owner 🧐 submitted by /u/Adept_Count3578 [link] [comments]
- 5 week old "pullet" crowed this morning 😳I was dozing in my recliner this morning, when hearing a noise from the brooder, my husband and son simultaneously exclaimed "what the heck was that?" Thirty seconds later I, too, heard the noise. I knew immediately what the heck it was. My five week old TSC cream legbar "pullet", purchased at a day or so old, (they are auto-sexing, correct?) crowed. It was definitely a crow and it continued to crow three or four more times. I have four roosters, (three silkie, one silkie/buff orpington) and the clarity of this crow put them all to shame. I've never had this breed before so was it possible or likely that a cockrell chick got mixed in with the pullets and I unawares chose it? They only had pullets of this breed. Is it possible or likely that she has heard the adult roosters crowing and mimicked them? Either way, 5 weeks old! I did notice the large comb and wattles but not being familiar with legbars, and trusting the "pullets" label, I didn't give it much thought. Well, shame on me for not doing my research before buying. submitted by /u/annphillips1980 [link] [comments]